Stop Otters From Being Illegally Killed in Austria
- van: Margherita B
- ontvanger: Herrn Landesrat
Lower Austria is planning to trap and shoot otters at the end of February 2017. The Eurasian otter, Lutra lutra, is only just recovering from a century-long decrease in Austria, one of the European hotspots for otter recolonisation.
Lower Austria, as part of European Union (EU), must follow the European Union Fauna and Flora Habitat Directive which places the otter under complete protection.
The reason for the culling is the result of pressure from fish farmers and anglers, that claim economic loss. An analysis of the situation shows that there are many reasons that cause fish declines. When anglers stock rivers, for example, with farm-raised fish such as salmonoids, these fish have no adequate anti-predator behaviour and are easily caught by otters.
Culling is not a solution. Studies have shown that when an otter is removed from an area, another otter will quickly occupy that territory again. There are many proven mitigation measures that will keep otters out of fish ponds and therefore reduce economic loss. Furthermore, culling will be performed during the March-October breeding season: pregnant females as well as mothers with cubs could be killed.
The consequences are too dramatic to be imagined. That is why we are urging Lower Austria to stop and reconsider this detrimental plan that goes against European directives and conservation programs. Better long-term solutions can be found which will not imperil this charismatic species!
Dear Landesrat Dr. Pernkopf,
we heard that you are intending to reduce otters in Lower Austria by shooting and trapping. You believe that a reduction of otters, by hunting and trapping, will reduce damages to fish populations in fish farms and rivers to a level acceptable for the owners of fish farms and anglingright holders in rivers and streams. Fish losses may be caused by otters, but as you know, there may be many other reasons as well: new chemical burdens, hydro-powering, fish diseases, climate change, etc.
Since the otter was absent for decades in most of Central Europe, as was the case in Lower Austria, fish management at that time, both in rivers and in fish farms, was designed with no concern for possible otter predation. Now the otter is back and it may well be that unfortunately traditional fish management techniques may enhance otter predation, rather than reduce it. This is particularly true when people stock fish for angling purposes in rivers and streams.
Based on the territorial life style of the Eurasian otter and what we see from similar conflicts with other otter species we predict that:
- If you reduce otters locally, damages caused by the otters will only decrease momentarily, and the empty territories will be filled up again very quickly. When you do it on the large scale, you will affect the entire population, you will also affect otters in the neighbouring provinces of Austria, in Germany and in particular in the Czech Republic and the vice minister of environment of the Czech Republic has already expressed his concerns about your proposed reduction plans.
- A large scale reduction of otters goes against EU FFH directive and world-wide conservation goals. The reduction of otters will slow down and ultimately stop the natural recolonization of the Alps and neighbouring areas, which is a goal of both the EU directive and the IUCN Otter Specialist Group
- A minor reduction of otters will not reduce the damage caused, it will just be a temporary placebo. Anglers and fish-farmers will be angry again. Their willingness to illegally remove otters will grow. They will assume that since there has been an official eradication campaign, the species is no longer endangered and protected and can now be trapped with impunity
- Apart of negative effects on the wellbeing and recovery of otters in Central Europe, Austria would give a bad example to other countries where the threatened European otter occurs. How can we justify our protectionist attitudes towards elephants or tigers if we are unable to resolve conflicts with our own species?
I hope and believe that you understand that the otter conflict problem in Lower Austria is of significant importance for conflict species management not only in Austria, but in Europe. Please reconsider your plans and find other, more sophisticated methods to put in place.
Sincerely,
Margherita Bandini
Publishing and Media Officer
IUCN-SSC Otter Specialist Group
Door te tekenen accepteer je de servicevoorwaarden van Care2 U kunt uw e-mail abonnementen op elk gewenst moment beheren.
Lukt het niet om dit te tekenen? Laat het ons weten..